Insurance That Runs in the Family.
Family-owned, legacy-driven, and client-focused for four generations.

Casey Insurance: family-owned for 45+ years, crafting personalized home, auto, and umbrella insurance from multiple carriers. Protecting clients is our family's passion.

Get My Free Quote

TESTIMONIALS

What our clients are saying

Excellent service, with outstanding explanation of the smallest of details, while presenting us plenty of options! Christina & Dan have helped us make smart decisions about our coverages for years.

- Lorna M.

Dan and Christina are the absolute best! Whenever I need something they are always there to help and have made the whole process of getting insurance easy and painless. They treat you like family and it's nice to know they are on your side.

- Kristina S.

I've worked with the Casey Insurance Agency for years and they are the best. Everyone is knowledgeable, attentive and proactive considering my insurance needs. If you are looking for an honest and hard -working agency, this is it!

- Joe G.

The most important aspect of any insurance agency is communication. Casey agency has always been A+ in their responsiveness. Knowing the person on the other end of the line and their knowledge of you as a customer is priceless. I want to know I'm more than a name and a policy number. With Casey Agency you never feel that way.

- J.B. L

I can't say enough good things about the Casey Insurance Agency. I've been a customer of theirs for many years. No matter what questions I have about Insurance matters, Dan Casey and Christina Allen have been so eager to help me. I wouldn't trust any other agency. I highly recommend them!

- Annmarie R.

Go to More Reviews 🚩

FEATHURES

Why Trust Us?

Insurance doesn’t have to feel corporate. With us, it feels like home.

1

Insurance is complex—we educate so you're confident and covered.

2

100% five-star reviews on Google with 45+ years of experience

3

Operated by 3rd and 4th generation agents

4

Proudly family-owned and operated

5

We protect you like you’re part of the family

SERVICES

Tailored insurance for
every stage of life.

01

Home
Insurance

The right homeowners insurance protects more than your home—it protects your family. As independent agents, we tailor coverage that fits, so you're protected when it matters most.

02

Auto
Insurance

Accidents happen—and the wrong coverage can cost you. We help you find auto insurance that protects your car, your finances, and your future.

03

Umbrella
Insurance

Umbrella insurance adds extra protection when the unexpected strikes—kicking in after your primary coverage limits are reached to help protect your home, savings, and future.

04

Life
Insurance

Life insurance helps protect your assets and gives your family peace of mind—so they’re financially secure, no matter what the future holds.

05

Medicare Gap Coverage

Retirement is no time for surprise medical bills. Tailored Medicare solutions help cover the gaps, keeping your out-of-pocket costs low when it matters most.

06

Health
Insurance

Health insurance can be overwhelming. With the right agent, you get clear guidance, honest answers, and a plan that fits your needs and budget.

Go to Insurance Form

ABOUT

All about
Us

After seeing the limits of working with just one carrier, we became independent to offer real choice. Now, we match you with the right coverage—not the other way around.
We take time to explain your policy in plain terms, so you’re never left guessing. Many agents skip that—we never will.
Family-owned with decades of experience, we treat every client like one of our own.